Class 11 : English Compulsory – Lesson 11. The Summer of the Beautiful White Horse
EXPLANATION & SUMMARY
🔵 EXPLANATION
🌿 “The Summer of the Beautiful White Horse” is a nostalgic and heartwarming short story by William Saroyan. It reflects themes of honesty, innocence, and childhood mischief, set against the backdrop of Armenian culture. Let’s break down the story step by step as it appears in the NCERT textbook:
🟢 Introduction: Setting the Scene
The narrator, Aram, begins by describing the unique traits of the Garoghlanian tribe, to which he belongs.
✔️ The tribe is known for two qualities: extreme poverty and a deep sense of honesty.
✔️ Despite their poverty, stealing was considered unthinkable in their community.
✏️ Note: This introduction sets up a contrast that makes the coming events more intriguing.
🟢 Mourad and the White Horse: A Surprising Sight
One early morning, Aram (then nine years old) is woken up by his cousin Mourad, who is sitting on a beautiful white horse.
🟢 Key Points:
Mourad, 13, is described as being “crazy” like his uncle Khosrove, known for his eccentric behavior.
Aram is shocked because he knows they could never afford such a horse.
💡 Concept: Here the story establishes Mourad’s adventurous nature and Aram’s innocence.
🟢 Aram’s Dilemma: Excitement vs. Conscience
Aram is torn between his excitement at the sight of the horse and his knowledge that their tribe forbids stealing.
🌿 His Rationalization:
He convinces himself that it might not be stealing if they only keep the horse for a while and then return it.
This shows his childish attempt to align fun with moral values.
✏️ Note: Saroyan cleverly captures the moral confusion of children.
🟢 A Ride with Mourad: Carefree Moments
Mourad lets Aram ride the horse, and they both enjoy a thrilling adventure across the countryside.
🔵 Mourad’s Confidence:
Mourad rides like a natural horseman, suggesting a deep connection with animals.
He calms the horse with a gentle, understanding approach, almost as if he can communicate with it.
🌿 This carefree episode contrasts with the underlying tension about the horse’s origin.
🟢 The Owner of the Horse: John Byro’s Visit
The plot thickens when John Byro, a neighbor, visits Aram’s house.
🟡 Key Details:
Byro mentions his white horse has been missing for over a month.
Aram’s uncle Khosrove responds comically, saying, “It’s no harm. Pay no attention to it.”
💡 Concept: Uncle Khosrove’s dismissive attitude adds humor and highlights the family’s quirky character.
🟢 Mourad’s Decision: A Test of Honesty
Mourad and Aram realize they can’t keep the horse any longer. Mourad, despite his love for the animal, decides to return it to John Byro’s barn.
✔️ This act shows the boys’ growing sense of responsibility and respect for their family’s values.
✏️ Note: Mourad’s choice reflects maturity and a deep understanding of the Garoghlanian moral code.
🟢 The Resolution: John Byro’s Gratitude
Later, John Byro reports to Aram’s family that his horse has returned. He comments that the horse seems healthier and better tempered.
🌿 Symbolism:
The horse returning better than before symbolizes how the boys, though mischievous, never meant harm and even cared for the animal lovingly.
💡 Concept: The ending ties back to the tribe’s reputation for honesty, reinforcing the idea that their integrity remained intact.
🟢 Themes and Messages
🔹 Honesty and Integrity: The story explores the Garoghlanian tribe’s deep commitment to moral values.
🔹 Childhood Innocence: Aram and Mourad’s actions come from curiosity and youthful excitement rather than malice.
🔹 Heritage and Identity: The narrative celebrates Armenian culture and family honor.
🔹 Compassion for Animals: Mourad’s gentle handling of the horse highlights empathy and care.
✏️ Tip for Students: Notice how Saroyan mixes humor, warmth, and ethical lessons without being preachy.
🟢 SUMMARY (300 Words)
🌿 “The Summer of the Beautiful White Horse” by William Saroyan is a touching story about two young Armenian boys, Aram and Mourad, who temporarily take a horse belonging to their neighbor, John Byro.
🔹 Key Points:
The Garoghlanian tribe, though extremely poor, is known for honesty.
Mourad brings a beautiful white horse to Aram’s house one morning. Aram, shocked but excited, joins Mourad for rides.
They enjoy their adventures but are troubled by the thought of stealing.
John Byro visits Aram’s house, lamenting his lost horse. Uncle Khosrove dismisses his concerns humorously.
Feeling guilty, Mourad decides to return the horse quietly.
John Byro later comments that his horse has come back healthier and more obedient.
💡 Takeaways:
The story reflects themes of morality, innocence, and cultural pride.
It beautifully balances humor and serious lessons about values and growing up.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
QUESTIONS FROM TEXTBOOK
🌿 Selected Paragraph (6 lines):
“It was morning, and the sun was shining on the rooftops when I saw my cousin Mourad sitting on a beautiful white horse. I couldn’t believe my eyes. We were poor, and it was unthinkable for us to have a horse. Yet there he was, smiling as if it were the most natural thing in the world. My heart pounded with excitement and confusion.”
🔵 Q1: MCQ – Antonym
Which word in the paragraph is opposite in meaning to “believable”?
(A) Excitement
(B) Unthinkable
(C) Natural
(D) Morning
✔️ Answer: (B) Unthinkable
🟢 Q2: One-line Answer
➡️ Why was Aram shocked to see Mourad on the horse?
✔️ Answer: Because their family was poor, and owning a horse was unimaginable for them.
🟡 Q3: 30-word Answer
➡️ How does Aram describe Mourad’s reaction while sitting on the horse?
✔️ Answer: Mourad appeared calm and confident, smiling naturally as though it was ordinary for him to have a horse, which contrasted sharply with Aram’s shock and confusion.
🔴 Q4: 60-word Answer
➡️ Explain how this paragraph sets the tone for the story’s main theme.
✔️ Answer: This paragraph introduces the central conflict—how two poor Armenian boys encounter a moral dilemma when faced with the temptation of a horse. Aram’s shock and Mourad’s calmness highlight their contrasting natures and foreshadow their innocent yet ethically complex adventure. It also hints at themes of honesty, childhood innocence, and family values in the Garoghlanian tribe.
————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
OTHER IMPORTANT QUESTIONS FOR EXAMS
🔵 Q1: Why did Aram initially justify Mourad’s action of taking the horse?
✔️ Answer: Aram convinced himself it wasn’t stealing because they didn’t intend to sell or keep the horse forever. He believed they were only borrowing it to ride for a few days, showing his childish innocence.
🟢 Q2: How does the story highlight the Garoghlanian tribe’s reputation?
✔️ Answer: The tribe was known for honesty and never stealing despite their poverty. This reputation creates irony because Mourad’s act of taking the horse goes against their values, causing internal conflict for Aram.
🟡 Q3: What does Mourad’s behavior towards the horse reveal about his character?
✔️ Answer: Mourad showed gentleness, patience, and a natural understanding of animals. His ability to calm and ride the horse effortlessly reflects his free spirit and deep connection with nature, despite his mischievous streak.
🔴 Q4: Why is John Byro’s reaction on seeing the boys with the horse significant?
✔️ Answer: John Byro recognized his horse but didn’t accuse the boys directly because of the tribe’s reputation for honesty. His faith and indirect approach stirred guilt in Mourad, prompting him to return the horse.
🟣 Q5: How does the story reflect the theme of innocence versus moral responsibility?
✔️ Answer: The boys’ actions stem from innocence and a love for adventure, not malice. However, as they grapple with their tribe’s values and Byro’s trust, they learn the importance of moral responsibility and returning the horse.
🔶 Q6: Analyse how The Summer of the Beautiful White Horse balances humor, morality, and childhood adventure. (120 words)
✔️ Answer: William Saroyan skillfully blends humor, morality, and adventure through Aram and Mourad’s escapade. The boys’ innocence makes their moral conflict amusing yet thought-provoking. Mourad’s quirky nature and his uncle Khosrove’s exaggerated outbursts add comic relief. Simultaneously, the narrative explores deeper themes like the Garoghlanian tribe’s strong moral code and the internal struggle between youthful mischief and family honor. The story ends on a positive note with the boys returning the horse, showing growth in their understanding of responsibility. This balance makes the story relatable and engaging, offering valuable life lessons while celebrating the joy and curiosity of childhood.
————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————